Looking for a great lip liner? You'll want to check out the NYX retractable waterproof lip liners. I bought these a while back at Ulta. It was an impulse buy because I was actually looking for another NYX lip product that they were out of. I'm glad I picked these up. They go on very smoothly and the color is rich. I'm not sure about the claims of actually being waterproof, but they will last a seriously long time. They are so pigmented, you could easily use them as an all over lip color and pair with a gloss. I was really impressed and I like the two colors I chose. If you've tried these, I'd love to know your thoughts.